Building a High-Performing Procurement Team

Procurement excellence is not built on systems alone. It is built on people.
Our latest article unpacks how to attract, retain, and develop a high-performing procurement team capable of delivering measurable business impact.

From modern role definitions to targeted development, performance culture, and future skills, this blueprint helps leaders build talent pipelines that strengthen resilience, innovation, and value creation.

Building a High-Performing Procurement Team

Brought to you by Duja Consulting

Introduction: Procurement as a Strategic Talent Game

Procurement has shifted from a transactional back-office function to a strategic value creator. Boards and executive teams increasingly expect procurement to unlock cost savings, manage risk, support sustainability goals, and secure supply resilience in an uncertain world. Technology, data, and automation are critical enablers – but they are not enough. The real differentiator is talent.

High-performing procurement teams are built deliberately. They combine commercial acumen, stakeholder savvy, data literacy, risk awareness, and ethical judgement. They operate as business partners, not order takers. They are measured on outcomes, not activity. And they are nurtured through a clear talent strategy spanning attraction, selection, onboarding, development, performance management, and succession planning.

This article outlines a practical roadmap for building and sustaining a high-performing procurement team that delivers measurable impact. It focuses on three core pillars: attracting the right people, retaining and engaging them, and developing their capability to keep pace with the organisation’s ambitions.

1. Start with a Clear Procurement Ambition and Talent Blueprint

You cannot build a high-performing team without clarity on what “high performance” means in your context. The starting point is a clear procurement ambition that aligns with corporate strategy and cascades into a talent blueprint.

Key actions:

• Define procurement’s mandate
  Is procurement primarily focused on cost optimisation, or is it also mandated to drive innovation, supplier collaboration, risk reduction, sustainability and transformation? Your talent needs will differ depending on the emphasis.
• Translate strategy into capability requirements
  For example:
  • Cost leadership → strong analytics, category management, negotiation, financial modelling.
  • Risk and resilience → supplier risk assessment, scenario planning, contract risk allocation.
  • Sustainability and localisation → knowledge of ESG standards, local supplier development, regulatory requirements.
  • Innovation → curiosity, cross-functional collaboration, design thinking, supplier-enabled innovation.
• Create role families and competency frameworks
  Define what “good” looks like for:
  • Category managers
  • Strategic sourcing specialists
  • Supplier relationship managers
  • Procurement analysts
  • Governance and compliance specialists
  • Transactional buying / P2P roles
• Anchor performance metrics in business outcomes
  Move beyond “savings only.” Include:
  • Total cost of ownership
  • Risk exposure reduction
  • Supplier performance and service levels
  • Contract compliance and leakage reduction
  • ESG and localisation targets
  • Internal customer satisfaction

This blueprint becomes the foundation for recruitment profiles, development plans, and performance management.

2. Build a Compelling Procurement Employer Brand

The best procurement talent now has options: consulting, technology providers, start-ups, and progressive corporates. To attract them, procurement must be positioned as a place where careers can flourish, not a cost-cutting silo.

Practical steps:

• Tell a strategic story about procurement internally and externally
  • Showcase procurement’s role in major strategic initiatives – market entries, product launches, cost transformation, ESG commitments.
  • Publish case studies and success stories that highlight impact, not just process.
• Highlight career paths and learning opportunities
  Candidates want stretch. Make it clear that procurement offers:
  • Cross-functional exposure (finance, operations, supply chain, sustainability)
  • Access to senior stakeholders
  • Opportunities to lead cross-border or cross-business projects
• Partner with HR and branding teams
  Ensure job adverts, careers pages, and recruitment campaigns avoid outdated language (“purchasing clerk”, “administrative buying”) and instead emphasise:
  • Strategic influence
  • Data and technology
  • Supplier and stakeholder leadership
  • Purpose and sustainability
• Engage with talent communities
  • Join and contribute to professional associations and online forums.
  • Sponsor hackathons, case competitions, or university challenges focused on procurement and supply chain.
  • Encourage team members to share thought leadership on professional platforms.

A clear, modern narrative about procurement’s significance will attract candidates who want to make a strategic difference.

3. Design Selection Processes that Identify Future-Fit Competencies

Traditional hiring for procurement has often over-weighted years of experience and under-weighted mindset and potential. High-performing teams require more nuanced selection.

Key design principles:

• Hire for learning agility, stakeholder skills, and ethics – not just technical experience
  Beyond basic procurement knowledge, assess:
  • Ability to learn new tools and concepts quickly
  • Comfort with ambiguity and change
  • Influence, communication, and relationship-building
  • Integrity and courage to challenge inappropriate practices
• Use structured interviews and practical case studies
  • Present candidates with realistic sourcing scenarios, supplier disputes, or stakeholder conflicts.
  • Ask them to walk through their approach: analysis, stakeholder engagement, risk assessment, negotiation strategy, and follow-through.
  • Use scoring rubrics to reduce bias and increase consistency.
• Incorporate data and digital competence assessments
  • Test basic numeracy, Excel or business intelligence skills, and ability to interpret dashboards.
  • For more advanced roles, assess familiarity with category analytics, spend segmentation, or predictive risk indicators.
• Involve cross-functional stakeholders in final interviews
  • Obtain feedback from internal “customers” (e.g., operations, finance, marketing).
  • Assess chemistry, communication style, and ability to understand business needs.
• Be explicit about the performance culture
  During selection, be clear about:
  • Measurable targets
  • Expectation of continuous improvement
  • The need to balance compliance with pragmatism and business value

Strong selection improves quality of hire and reduces downstream issues around performance and culture fit.

4. Onboard with Intent: Set the Tone for Performance from Day One

High-performing teams are shaped early. Poor onboarding leads to slow ramp-up, confusion, and disengagement. Intentional onboarding accelerates contribution and embeds culture.

Elements of an effective procurement onboarding:

• Structured induction plan (first 90 days)
  • Week-by-week exposure to key processes: sourcing, contracting, supplier onboarding, governance, and systems.
  • Meetings with key internal stakeholders and business partners.
  • Shadowing senior team members in negotiations, supplier meetings, and steering committees.
• Clear role expectations and metrics
  • Agree on initial objectives: for example, “take ownership of X category”, “stabilise Y supplier relationship”, or “deliver a diagnostic on Z spend area.”
  • Explain how performance will be evaluated and what “good” looks like in your culture.
• Assign a mentor or buddy
  • Someone who can explain unwritten norms, help navigate politics, and answer questions that people may be reluctant to ask in group settings.
• Provide early exposure to quick wins
  • Identify opportunities where the new hire can deliver visible improvements – a process fix, a data clean-up, a small sourcing project – to build confidence and internal credibility.

Onboarding done well signals that procurement is a professional, structured environment that values people’s time and contribution.

5. Create a Development Architecture, Not One-Off Training Events

High-performing procurement teams are built through ongoing capability development, not sporadic courses. A development architecture links skills, experiences, and coaching to business outcomes.

Key components:

• Role-based learning pathways
  • For each role family, define a pathway covering:
    • Fundamentals (e.g., sourcing process, category strategies, contract basics)
    • Intermediate skills (e.g., advanced negotiation, total cost modelling, supplier performance management)
    • Advanced and leadership skills (e.g., influencing executives, leading cross-functional transformation, supplier collaboration for innovation)
• Blend formal training with applied projects
  • Combine classroom or online learning with live projects.
  • Use “learn-apply-review” cycles where individuals:
    • Learn a concept (e.g., should-cost modelling)
    • Apply it to a real category
    • Review outcomes with a mentor or manager
• Develop commercial and financial acumen
  • Offer training on reading financial statements, understanding margins, and modelling commercial scenarios.
  • Teach how procurement decisions affect income statements, balance sheets, and cash flow.
• Strengthen soft skills and leadership
  • Communication, conflict resolution, stakeholder engagement, and change management are often the differentiators.
  • Provide opportunities to present to senior leadership, lead working groups, or facilitate supplier review meetings.
• Leverage digital tools and data literacy
  • Train teams to use procurement and analytics platforms effectively.
  • Build comfort with data interpretation, visualisation, and storytelling to ensure insights translate into action.

A coherent development architecture ensures that capability building is cumulative and aligned with strategic needs, rather than ad hoc.

6. Embed a Performance Culture with Clear Metrics and Feedback

High-performing teams know how they are performing and what needs to improve. That requires transparent metrics and regular, constructive feedback.

Practical approaches:

• Define a balanced scorecard for procurement
  • Financial: cost avoidance, cost reduction, working capital improvements.
  • Risk: supplier concentration, dependency, contract coverage, audit findings.
  • Service: internal customer satisfaction, request cycle times, on-time delivery.
  • Sustainability and compliance: adherence to policies, ESG and localisation targets, ethical sourcing.
• Cascade team KPIs into individual objectives
  • Each role should have 3–5 clear objectives linked to the broader scorecard.
  • Avoid volumes-based metrics (e.g., number of purchase orders raised) as primary measures; focus on outcomes and quality.
• Institutionalise regular performance conversations
  • Monthly check-ins to review progress, address barriers, and recalibrate priorities.
  • Quarterly reviews to discuss development, longer-term goals, and stretch opportunities.
• Reward both results and behaviours
  • Recognise not only savings, but also:
    • Improved stakeholder relationships
    • Innovative sourcing solutions
    • Risk mitigation and issue prevention
    • Coaching and knowledge-sharing contributions
• Use data to drive accountability and coaching
  • Dashboards showing category performance, contract coverage, and supplier risk can fuel informed discussions.
  • Use insights to identify where additional support, training, or process improvements are needed.

A robust performance culture encourages ownership, reduces complacency, and signals that procurement is a serious, results-focused discipline.

7. Build a Strong Team Culture: Collaboration, Ethics, and Psychological Safety

Technical skill without the right culture rarely delivers sustainable performance. The best procurement teams combine commercial edge with ethical integrity and psychological safety.

Key cultural attributes:

• Collaboration over silos
  • Encourage cross-category and cross-function collaboration, particularly for complex initiatives.
  • Rotate team members through different categories or business units to build empathy and break down barriers.
• Ethical courage and compliance
  • Make it clear that shortcuts, conflicts of interest, and opaque supplier relationships are unacceptable.
  • Provide channels for raising concerns without fear of retaliation.
  • Recognise and protect individuals who speak up about potential issues.
• Psychological safety and constructive challenge
  • Create an environment where team members can question assumptions, challenge decisions, and admit mistakes without being penalised.
  • Encourage debate on sourcing strategies, supplier choices, and risk trade-offs.
• Diversity of perspectives
  • Promote diversity in background, experience, and thinking styles.
  • Ensure everyone has a voice in key discussions, not just the most senior or outspoken.
• Shared identity and purpose
  • Communicate how procurement contributes to the organisation’s mission – whether that is customer value, innovation, sustainability, or social impact.
  • Celebrate team achievements publicly and link them to this purpose.

Culture is often the invisible force behind sustained high performance. Investing in it directly pays dividends in resilience, innovation, and retention.

8. Retain and Engage Talent through Meaningful Careers, Not Just Pay

Compensation must be competitive, but it is only one component of retention. High performers stay where they feel valued, stretched, and connected to something meaningful.

Retention strategies:

• Design visible career paths
  • Offer vertical progression (e.g., category manager to head of procurement) and horizontal moves (e.g., into supply chain, operations, finance, or sustainability).
  • Encourage short-term secondments into business units or project teams.
• Provide stretch assignments and special projects
  • Involve high-potential individuals in strategic initiatives: major tenders, technology implementations, or mergers and acquisitions.
  • Give them ownership of complex, ambiguous problems with appropriate support.
• Recognise and reward impact
  • Use non-financial recognition: awards, internal communications, opportunities to present to the executive team.
  • Ensure bonuses or incentives reflect both individual and team performance.
• Support work–life balance and wellbeing
  • Procurement can be intense, particularly during major sourcing events or crises. Offer:
    • Reasonable workload planning
    • Flexible working options where feasible
    • Access to wellness support and mental health resources
• Conduct regular “stay interviews”
  • Rather than waiting for exit interviews, ask key team members periodically:
    • What keeps you here?
    • What might cause you to leave?
    • What would make your work more rewarding?

Insights from these conversations should feed into both individual development and broader team changes.

9. Use Technology and Data to Amplify Talent, Not Replace It

Digital tools are reshaping procurement, but they should be seen as talent multipliers rather than substitutes. High-performing teams understand how to harness technology to focus human effort where it matters most.

Key principles:

• Automate transactional work to free up strategic capacity
  • Use e-procurement, guided buying, catalogues, and workflow tools to handle routine purchases and approvals.
  • Redeploy procurement professionals to higher-value activities: supplier collaboration, strategic sourcing, risk management.
• Equip the team with intuitive analytics
  • Provide spend dashboards, supplier risk scores, and performance reports that are easy to interpret and act upon.
  • Train people in data storytelling – turning numbers into compelling narratives that influence decisions.
• Involve the team in technology selection and design
  • End-user involvement improves adoption and ensures tools genuinely support workflows.
  • Use pilots and feedback loops to refine configurations before full rollout.
• Maintain a learning mindset about new technologies
  • Encourage curiosity about emerging tools: advanced analytics, automation, collaboration platforms.
  • Provide opportunities for experimentation and innovation within controlled boundaries.

When technology is positioned as an enabler of professional growth and impact, it becomes a retention lever, not a threat.

10. Plan for Succession and Future Skills

High-performing teams think several years ahead about which skills will be needed and who will provide them. Succession planning is not only about replacing senior leaders; it covers key roles across the function.

Succession actions:

• Identify critical roles and single points of failure
  • These may include key category managers, supplier relationship leads, and governance specialists.
  • Document key relationships, knowledge, and processes to reduce dependency on individuals.
• Assess potential, not just current performance
  • Use talent reviews to identify individuals with capacity to step into bigger roles.
  • Consider learning agility, resilience, and the ability to influence, not only past achievements.
• Create development plans for successors
  • Intentionally expose potential successors to the stakeholders, categories, and challenges they will face in future.
  • Use coaching, mentoring, and formal training to accelerate readiness.
• Monitor external trends in procurement skills
  • Keep track of emerging skill requirements: data and analytics, sustainability, risk modelling, supplier innovation, and geopolitical awareness.
  • Refresh your talent blueprint periodically to reflect these shifts.

A proactive approach to future skills reduces the risk of capability gaps and supports continuity of performance.

Conclusion: Procurement Talent as a Strategic Investment

Building a high-performing procurement team is not a one-off initiative; it is an ongoing strategic investment. The organisations that win will be those that:

• Define a clear procurement ambition and translate it into a tangible talent blueprint.
• Position procurement as a compelling career destination, not a transactional function.
• Hire for potential, learning agility, and stakeholder skills, supported by robust selection processes.
• Onboard intentionally, develop capabilities through structured pathways, and embed a performance culture grounded in data and outcomes.
• Foster a strong culture of ethics, collaboration, and psychological safety.
• Retain talent through meaningful careers, recognition, and growth opportunities.
• Leverage technology and data to amplify human strengths.
• Plan ahead for succession and future skills.

In a volatile world of supply disruptions, cost pressures, and rising expectations around sustainability and compliance, procurement talent is a decisive competitive advantage. By treating procurement capability-building as a strategic priority rather than an administrative task, organisations can unlock measurable impact in cost, risk, resilience, and innovation.

Duja Consulting partners with organisations to design and implement procurement operating models, governance, and talent strategies that translate into real-world performance. From capability assessments and competency frameworks to training programmes and change management, we help build procurement teams that deliver – and keep delivering – measurable value to the business.

Connect with Duja Consulting! Follow us on LinkedIn!